Just spotted on the r/HorrorMovies subreddit: a cinematic mystery that is driving the community into a digital frenzy. User /u/Interesting-Dog-5460 is on a high-stakes mission to track down a lost piece of mid-2010s carnage, and the details provided are as gruesome as they are specific. While we usually cover the latest blockbusters here at ScreamDesk, this "cold case" has caught our eye because the described plot sounds like a hidden gem of visceral horror that may have slipped through the cracks of history.
The Grisly Details: A Cabin, a Basement, and a Witch
According to the developing story on Reddit, the film in question follows three women in their early twenties who retreat to a rented cabin or house for a vacation. The narrative starts with a familiar trope—inviting a group of men over for a night of drinking—but quickly spirals into a nightmare. The user recalls the protagonists waking up with no memory of the previous night, only to discover a hidden door under the stairs.
Fresh from the rumor mill of the comments section, the description of what lies beneath is enough to make any gore-hound salivate. The women reportedly find the men they were partying with tied to chairs, dead and showing signs of extreme torture. The twist? This isn't a standard slasher. A local witch reportedly informs the women that they are the killers, possessed by an ancient entity that once inhabited the grounds. To protect themselves, they are given necklaces, but the user notes that one character (possibly a blonde) discards hers in an act of defiance. This skepticism leads to a full-blown possession, resulting in a finale involving the extraction of teeth and tongues to fill a bowl of ritualistic blood.
The 2015-2016 Timeline: A Clue to the Identity?
Take this with a grain of salt as it relies on a decade-old memory, but the user is certain they saw this movie in late 2015 or early 2016. They specifically remember watching it the same day they saw the horror-comedy Scouts Guide to the Zombie Apocalypse. This timeframe is crucial for our investigation. This era was a massive turning point for indie horror, as the industry shifted away from the "found footage" craze toward more polished, atmospheric supernatural films.
Analysis of the clues suggests we are looking for a title that likely had a limited theatrical run or was a heavy hitter on VOD services. The "necklace as protection" motif is a classic folk-horror element, while the extreme dental trauma suggests a filmmaker who wasn't afraid to lean into the "New French Extremity" influence that was still permeating the genre at the time. Could it be a lesser-known festival darling or perhaps a gritty international production that received an English dub?
Can You Solve This Horror Mystery?
The search is officially on. Despite the user's attempts to use AI to identify the film, the title remains elusive. We've seen similar "lost" films found through the power of the horror community before—sometimes it's a segment from an anthology, and other times it's a project that changed titles three times before landing on a streaming service. The specific detail of the "blonde throwing away the necklace" is the smoking gun we need.
If you have any leads or remember a movie from 2015 that features a basement full of tortured party-goers and a blood-drinking witch, the ScreamDesk team wants to know. This is a developing story, and we will update this post if the community manages to crack the case. In an era where every movie is supposedly at our fingertips, it's thrilling to find a piece of genre cinema that still feels like a dangerous, forbidden secret.